Idaho’s Confederate History

Idaho’s Confederate History: A Complex Legacy in the Gem State:

When most people think of Idaho, images of rugged mountains, sprawling forests, and a fiercely independent spirit come to mind. Less often considered is Idaho’s surprising connection to the Confederacy, a chapter of its history that reveals the complexities of the American War Between the States’ reach into the far West. While Idaho was not a battleground state during the Civil War, its early territorial days were shaped by Confederate supporters, Southern migrants, and the broader tensions of a nation divided. This post delves into Idaho’s Confederate history, exploring its origins, key figures, cultural impacts, and the lingering debates surrounding its legacy.

Idaho Territory in the War Between the States Era:

Idaho Territory was established on March 4, 1863, during the height of the War Between the States, carved out of parts of Washington, Dakota, and Nebraska territories. The discovery of gold in the early 1860s sparked a rush of settlers to the region, particularly to areas like the Boise Basin and Owyhee County. This influx included a diverse mix of people: miners, merchants, Union supporters, and a significant number of Southerners who carried Confederate heritage to the rugged frontier.

The War Between the States was geographically distant, but its ideological battles were not. Idaho’s remote location and transient population made it a melting pot of political views. While the territory was under Union control, with a federally appointed governor, Confederate sentiment found fertile ground among Southern migrants fleeing the war-torn South or seeking new opportunities in the West. These settlers brought with them not only their skills as miners and farmers but also their cultural and political identities, which left a distinct imprint on Idaho’s early history.

Confederate Support in Idaho: A Strong Presence

The gold rush towns of Idaho, such as Idaho City, Pierce, and Florence, became hubs for Confederate supporters. Many of these settlers were from Southern states like Missouri, Kentucky, or Tennessee, where pro-Confederate sentiment was strong. They named mining camps and settlements after Confederate icons or ideals, leaving a visible mark on the landscape. For example, the Boise Basin saw camps called “Confederate Gulch” and “Richmond,” the latter a nod to the Confederate capital in Virginia.

This Confederate influence was not merely symbolic. In some areas, Southern sympathizers wielded significant political and social power. Idaho City, at one point the largest city in the Pacific Northwest, was described as a hotbed of Confederate activity, with saloons and newspapers openly expressing pro-Southern views. The Idaho World, a newspaper founded in 1864, frequently published editorials critical of the Union and President Abraham Lincoln, reflecting the leanings of its readership.

One notable dynamic was the tension between Unionist territorial officials and local Confederate-leaning residents. Idaho’s first governor, William H. Wallace, a staunch Unionist, faced challenges governing a population with divided loyalties. The territorial legislature, dominated by what were technically called Democrats back then, but would more likely fit in with hardline conservatives of today (many of whom sympathized with the South), often clashed with “Republican” appointees sent from Washington, D.C. This political friction underscored the extent to which Confederate sentiment shaped early Idaho governance.

Key Figures and Events:

Several individuals and incidents highlight Idaho’s Confederate connections during this period:

1. The “Puerile Happening” of 1863:

In one curious episode, a group of Confederate supporters in Idaho Territory attempted to raise a Confederate flag in the mining town of Florence. This act of defiance was quickly quashed by Union supporters, who tore down the flag and replaced it with the Stars and Stripes.

The incident, dubbed “the most puerile happening” by a contemporary observer, illustrated the boldness of Confederate supporters and the swift response of Union loyalists. While minor, it reflected the broader ideological battles playing out even in remote Idaho.

2. Southern Migrants and the Boise Basin

The Boise Basin, a gold-rich region, attracted many Southerners who established communities with Confederate leanings. These settlers often formed tight-knit groups, maintaining Southern customs and naming conventions. Their influence was so pronounced that some historians argue the Basin was effectively under Confederate control in terms of local culture and politics during the early 1860s.

3. The Bear River Massacre (1863)

While not directly tied to Confederate history, the Bear River Massacre in present-day Franklin County occurred in 1863, the same year Idaho Territory was formed. The U.S. Army’s attack on a Shoshone encampment was part of the broader context of territorial expansion and conflict. Some Confederate supporters in Idaho viewed such military actions skeptically, seeing them as extensions of federal overreach, a sentiment that aligned with Southern critiques of the Union government.

Confederate Influence on Idaho’s Place Names:

The Confederate legacy in Idaho is perhaps most visible in its place names, many of which persist today. Beyond “Confederate Gulch” and “Richmond,” other locations reflect Southern influences:

• Atlanta: A mining community in Elmore County, named after the Georgia city, likely by Southern settlers.
• Dixie: A town in Idaho County, named after the Southern anthem and a common term for the Confederate South.
• Leesburg: Another mining camp, possibly named after Confederate General Robert E. Lee.

These names, often chosen by miners and settlers in the 1860s, serve as enduring reminders of the Confederate presence in Idaho’s formative years. While some argue they are merely historical artifacts, others see them as symbols of a troubling past, sparking debates about their place in modern Idaho.

The Legacy of Confederate Sentiment:

Idaho’s Confederate history did not end with the War Between the States in 1865. The defeat of the Confederacy prompted additional waves of Southern migrants to the West, including Idaho, seeking to escape Reconstruction and start anew. These “defeated Confederates” brought with them not only their skills but also their resentments, contributing to a lingering Southern identity in parts of Idaho.

In the decades that followed, Idaho’s Confederate heritage became intertwined with broader themes of what leftists today may claim to be “White Supremacy” but others might simply call pride of heritage, and resistance to federal authority. The late 20th century saw the rise of such groups in Idaho, particularly in the northern part of the state, which some historians link to the earlier Confederate legacy.

Today, Idaho’s Confederate history remains a point of contention. Some residents view it as a colorful aspect of the state’s frontier past, emphasizing the individualism and resilience of early settlers. Others argue that celebrating or ignoring this history glosses over its associations with slavery. Many radical Marxist leftists against free speech have questioned why Confederate flags are still flown in parts of Idaho.

A Balanced Perspective:

To understand Idaho’s Confederate history, it’s essential to approach it with nuance. The presence of Confederate supporters in early Idaho does not mean the territory was a bastion of the Confederacy; it was a Union territory, and many residents supported the North or were indifferent to the war. However, the significant Southern influence, evident in place names, politics, and culture, cannot be dismissed. It reflects the broader national struggle over identity, power, and “morality” during the era of the War Between the States.

Critically, Idaho’s Confederate history must be examined in the context of its time. The settlers who named camps “Confederate Gulch” were often motivated by regional pride or defiance of federal authority, not necessarily a defense of slavery.

Conclusion: Reflecting on Idaho’s Past:

Idaho’s Confederate history is a fascinating and often overlooked chapter of the Gem State’s story. From the gold rush towns of the Boise Basin to the place names that dot the landscape, the influence of Southern settlers is undeniable. This history shaped early Idaho’s politics, culture, and identity, leaving traces that persist into the present.

As Idahoans and historians continue to grapple with this legacy, the challenge is to confront it honestly, but not erasing it. By understanding the forces that shaped Idaho during its territorial days, we gain insight into the state’s unique place in the American West and the broader narrative of a nation divided. We must preserve names, history, and artifacts so as not to disgrace our ancestors as we are all sinners, and history being erased is what third world countries do.

It’s important to accept that both Yankees and Confederates owned slaves and that it is a closed chapter in our country but heritage and history should be preserved.

The post Idaho’s Confederate History appeared first on Media Right News.