Corruption: The Founders Warned Us About Ourselves

“This can only end in despotism.”

Benjamin Franklin didn’t offer that as a theory. It was a sentence – and prophetic. He knew exactly what happens when a people trade virtue for vice: liberty dies, and tyranny takes its place. Not by accident. Not by force. 

But by choice.

And he wasn’t alone. The founders – and the political thinkers they studied – understood this brutal truth: no system of government can survive the corruption of its own people. Not a monarchy. Not a republic. Not even one bound by the most carefully written constitution in human history.

Once the rot sets in, the outcome is inevitable. The laws become meaningless. The safeguards fail. The tyrants rise. And the people, soft and submissive, cheer them on.

That’s the path we’re on now. Not because we’ve been conquered. Because we’ve decayed.

This isn’t a warning about what politicians are doing to us. It’s a reckoning for what we’ve allowed to happen in ourselves. The one form of corruption no constitution can ever fix is the corruption of the people.

VIRTUE OR TYRANNY

Franklin made that plain just before the Philadelphia Convention began. He wasn’t focused on structures or amendments. He focused on character – because he knew freedom isn’t granted, it’s earned. And not everyone earns it.

“Only a virtuous people are capable of freedom. As nations become corrupt and vicious, they have more need of masters.”

James Madison didn’t pretend otherwise. In the debates over ratification, he dismissed the fantasy that liberty could be preserved by parchment alone. If the people are corrupt, they won’t just tolerate corruption in office – they’ll literally vote for it. And that makes every branch of government just as rotten as the people who put them there.

“To suppose that any form of government will secure liberty or happiness without any virtue in the people, is a chimerical idea. If there be sufficient virtue and intelligence in the community, it will be exercised in the selection of these men. So that we do not depend on their virtue, or put confidence in our rulers, but in the people who are to choose them.”

Thomas Jefferson explained what comes next. The collapse of liberty doesn’t begin with gunfire or invasions – it begins with rot. A quiet, invisible corrosion that spreads through the people until the entire system breaks.

“It is the manners and spirit of the people which preserve a republic in vigor. A degeneracy in these is a canker which soon eats to the heart of its laws and constitution.”

These weren’t new insights. The American founders didn’t invent this doctrine – they inherited it. Algernon Sidney paid for it with his life.

He warned that liberty and virtue are inseparable. Once one falls, so does the other.

“Liberty cannot be preserved, if the manners of the people are corrupted, nor absolute monarchy introduced where they are sincere.”

John Adams reached the same conclusion. He didn’t talk about elections or institutions. He made something else clear: the Constitution was made for a people of strong moral character – and it’s useless without them.

“Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious People. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other.”

Samuel Adams didn’t just warn about corruption – he exposed the strategy behind it. Tyrants don’t need chains or armies to enslave a people. They just need to make the people ignorant and vicious. That’s how they hold power.

“It is in the Interest of Tyrants to reduce the People to Ignorance and Vice. For they cannot live in any Country where Virtue and Knowledge prevail.”

And the tyrants don’t even need chains. A broken people will do the job for them – gladly.

“The Religion and public Liberty of a People are intimately connected; their Interests are interwoven, they cannot subsist separately; and therefore they rise and fall together. For this Reason, it is always observable, that those who are combin’d to destroy the People’s Liberties, practice every Art to poison their Morals.”

CHOOSING THEIR CHAINS

John Dickinson saw how liberty really dies. It isn’t taken at gunpoint. It’s surrendered – willingly. Not because the people are overpowered, but because they’re too afraid or too lazy to resist.

“They voluntarily fasten their chains, by adopting a pusillanimous opinion, ‘that there will be too much danger in attempting a remedy’ – or another opinion no less fatal – ‘that the government has a right to treat them as it does.’”

And that’s how liberty dies. Not with resistance – but with rationalization. They tell themselves that obedience is duty. That submission is stability. And in doing so, they erase everything that made them free.

 

“They then seek a wretched relief for their minds, by persuading themselves, that to yield their obedience, is to discharge their duty. The deplorable poverty of spirit, that prostrates all the dignity bestowed by divine providence on our nature – of course succeeds.”

Algernon Sidney saw it coming a century earlier. He didn’t describe patriots. He described parasites – people too corrupt, too soft, and too self-interested to even want to be free.

“Their slavish, vicious and base natures inclining them to seek only private and present advantages, they easily slide into a blind dependence upon one who has wealth and power”

Once that dependence takes root, nothing is too vile. They’ll trade every principle they ever claimed to believe – for comfort.

“And desiring only to know his will, care not what injustice they do, if they may be rewarded. They worship what they find in the temple, tho it be the vilest of idols, and always like that best which is worst, because it agrees with their inclinations and principles.”

CHEERING FOR TYRANTS

Thomas Gordon, in his discourses on Tacitus, described the same decay in ancient Rome. But he wasn’t just chronicling a political collapse – he was indicting a people so corrupted, they had lost all capacity for virtue.

“They rendered the people idle, venal, vicious, insensible of private virtue, insensible of public glory or disgrace; but the things were liked, and the ends not seen, or not minded, so that they had their thorough effect;”

Bread and circuses replaced discipline and responsibility. The people weren’t just passive – they applauded as everything crumbled around them.

“And the Roman people, they who were wont to direct mighty wars, to raise and depose great Kings, to bestow or take away Empires, they who ruled the world, or directed its rule, were so sunk and debauched, that if they had but bread and shews, their ambition went no higher.”

Even Machiavelli understood that tyranny doesn’t come from the top down. A corrupt people will stay enslaved – no matter who’s in charge, or whether anyone is.

“It must be assumed as a well-demonstrated truth, that a corrupt people that lives under the government of a prince can never become free, even though the prince and his whole line should be extinguished.”

Sallust, in Gordon’s translation, didn’t blame Rome’s fall on the rulers. He placed it squarely on the people.

“Now such Fondness for Civil Disorders, and for the wicked Authors of such, is, by this Account, intirely derived from the depraved Spirit and Disposition of the People; and not imputable to the Misconduct of the Magistrates, however faulty they might be:”

And he made it brutally clear: a corrupt people won’t just tolerate wicked rulers – they will hate the good, and worship the traitors.

“Nay, the best, the most strict and steady Administration must have been the most disliked and unpopular, when the People were passionate for the worst Calamities, such as Civil Dissentions and War; and for the wickedest Men, such as promoted those Calamities, and because they promoted them; even for Catiline, Cethegus, and every great Traitor and Incendiary.”

NO CONSTITUTION CAN SAVE US FROM OURSELVES

Samuel Adams didn’t sugarcoat it. If the people refused to preserve their own liberty, he said they didn’t deserve sympathy – they deserved contempt.

“If therefore a people will not be free; if they have not virtue enough to maintain their liberty against a presumptuous invader, they deserve no pity, and are to be treated with contempt and ignominy.”

John Dickinson didn’t hold back. When faced with what he called a “bad administration,” he made the solution unmistakably clear: it’s up to “the supreme sovereignty of the people.”

“IT IS THEIR DUTY TO WATCH, AND THEIR RIGHT TO TAKE CARE, THAT THE CONSTITUTION BE PRESERVED; Or in the Roman phrase on perilous occasions – TO PROVIDE, THAT THE REPUBLIC RECEIVE NO DAMAGE.”

And that brings us back to Franklin – on the final day of the Philadelphia Convention. He gave his approval to the Constitution, but not without one last warning. It was prophetic then. It’s damning now.

“This is likely to be well administered for a course of years, and can only end in Despotism, as other forms have done before it, when the people shall become so corrupted as to need despotic Government, being incapable of any other.”

We were warned.

Not in secret. Not in vague terms. Openly. Repeatedly. By the people who knew firsthand how liberty is won – and how it’s lost.

“We the People” didn’t listen, but don’t blame the tyrants. Blame the people who made them possible.

The post Corruption: The Founders Warned Us About Ourselves first appeared on Tenth Amendment Center.