California Superintendent Vetoes Measure to Fly Israeli Flag at Schools

A California superintendent has nixed plans to display the Israeli flag on the grounds of campuses administered by the Beverly Hills Unified School District, overruling a decision reached by the local school board because he said the gesture may provoke a security threat.

“In light of heightened safety concerns around the displaying of flags on our campuses I have made the decision to take immediate action for the safety and security of our students,” BHUSD superintendent Alex Cherniss, a Republican, said in a statement. “Until further notice, no flags will be displayed on our campuses other than the flag of the United States of America and the flag of the State of California.”

As first reported by The Los Angeles Times, the move exercised Cherniss’s veto power over measures approved by the Beverly Hills Board of Education at a time when its voting to fly the Israeli flag was piquing a bitter dispute which functioned as an extension of a larger dialogue about the war in Gaza and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The Times added that the board intended to show solidarity with the Jewish community amid rising antisemitism throughout the world.

Another outlet, the Beverly Hills Courier, reported that the resolution which included the measure also established observance of Jewish Heritage Month in May and adopted the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism, a reference tool used by governments and organizations across the world. Local leaders, some of whom are Jewish, told the paper that flying the flag would constitute a gratuitous partisan action which undermined the spirit of their intentions.

“Just about two months ago, we spoke about how partisan materials — as an example, a Greek flag — would not be allowed,” Board of Education member Amanda Stern, who voted against the resolution because of the flag provision, told the Courier. “We really need to look at that so there is not preferential treatment for one group over another.

Rachelle Marcus, who is president of the board and joined Stern in opposing the resolution, told the Courier, “I don’t want to put something on the front of the school that will make us targets of any kind, especially with the students in our school.” However, others hold conflicting opinions, including board member Russell Stuart, who downplayed the significance of the symbolism of the Israeli flag, arguing that it “is not a direct endorsement of the Israeli government” or a “direct endorsement of any geopolitical topic.”

“It is support for our Jewish students and the Jewish community,” he added.

Antisemitism in K-12 schools is receiving increased attention, notably in California, after years of falling under the radar.

Last month, The Algemeiner reported that the Santa Clara Unified School District (SCUSD), which stands accused of refusing to address antisemitism, ruled that a teacher who allegedly showed her students antisemitic, discriminatory, and biased content violated policy when she screened an offensive video about the Holocaust in her classroom.

The move came without the prompting of the US Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights, with which two Jewish civil rights groups, StandWithUs (SWU) and the Bay Area Jewish Coalition (BAJC), filed a complaint against the district in April.

Among other things, SWU and BAJC alleged that an SCUSD employee, Wilcox High School teacher Kauser Adenwala, screened a documentary produced in Turkey which compared the war in Gaza to the Holocaust. The graphic film at one point “displays a picture of a young Jewish child who was branded with a number by the Nazis during World War II and then suddenly shows an untraceable image of children with Arabic writing on their arms,” according to the complaint, which alleged the teacher’s conduct violated numerous district policies and potentially state law. However, she remains employed by the district to this day.

The district subsequently investigated the incident and said in an official letter that was just sent to BAJC on July 25 and obtained by The Algemeiner that Adenwala breached the Governing Board’s policies.

In April, a civil rights complaint filed by StandWithUs and the Bay Area Jewish Coalition alleged that the SCUSD allows Jewish students to be subjected to unconscionable levels of antisemitic bullying in and outside of the classroom.

The 27-page complaint, filed with the US Education Department, described a slew of incidents that allegedly fostered a hostile environment for Jewish students after Hamas’s Oct. 7, 2023, atrocities set off a wave of anti-Jewish hatred across the US. SCUSD students, the complaint said, graffitied antisemitic hate speech in the bathrooms, vandalized Jewish-themed posters displayed in schools, and distributed stickers which said, “F—k Zionism.” All the while, district officials enabled the behavior by refusing to investigate it and blaming victims who came forward to report their experiences, according to the complaint.

“SCUSD has allowed an egregiously hostile environment to fester for its Jewish and Israeli students in violation of its federal obligations and ethical responsibility to create a safe educational space for all students,” Jenna Statfeld Harris, senior counsel and K-12 specialist at StandWithUs Saidoff Legal, said in a statement at the time. “SCUSD leadership repeatedly disregards the rights of their Jewish and Israeli students. We implore the Office for Civil Rights to step in and uphold the right of these students to an inclusive education free from hostility toward their protected identity.”

In August, the Education Department promptly opened an investigation into allegations of antisemitism in Baltimore City Public Schools (BCPS) following the Anti-Defamation League’s (ADL) filing a complaint regarding the matter.

Jewish students allegedly experienced relentless bullying in BCPS, where students pantomimed Nazi salutes, treated campuses as a canvas for Nazi-inspired and antisemitic graffiti, and sent text messages threatening that the Palestinian terrorist group Hamas will be summoned to kill Jewish students the bullies do not like, the ADL complaint said, noting that teachers behaved even worse than students. At Bard High School, an English teacher performed the Nazi salute three times and later admitted to administrative officials that he did so intentionally to harm “the sole Jewish student” enrolled in his class. Following the incident, he suggested that the student unregister for his class because the Israeli-Palestinian conflict would be discussed in it.

“The allegations that Baltimore City Public Schools tolerate virulent Nazi-inspired antisemitic harassment of its Jewish students is at once appalling and infuriating. When a teacher allegedly directs a Nazi salute toward a Jewish student, or non-Jewish students harass their Jewish contemporaries by saying ‘all Jews should die,’ we are not simply talking about contemptible bullying; we are talking about a shocking abdication of educator responsibility that constitutes unlawful antisemitic harassment under Title VI,” Craig Trainor, acting assistant secretary for civil rights, said in a statement announcing the action.

Follow Dion J. Pierre @DionJPierre.